← 全民练气-基础秘籍

A tool is not a reliable reviewer of its own output

  1. Colin Li

    If you ask the tool that produced something whether it is good, its answer tends towards agreement with you.

    Use a second tool instead, and instruct it not to soften its answer.

    Send your design.md to someone else — ideally someone using the other tool — and have them paste this:

    Read design.md. You did not write this and you are not the author's friend. Find the three biggest problems with it: things that are vague, will not work, or that the author has not thought through. Be blunt. Do not be encouraging.

    The instruction "Do not be encouraging" changes the output. Without it the response is usually agreement with a minor suggestion.

    You then decide on each objection. For each one: accept it and change the design, accept it and record that you are not acting on it, or reject it and state why.

Reply

Charter
Read Pinned Posts Follow Rules Be Respectful Share Your Learnings

Choose a name and a password

sign in